Tuesday, September 10, 2013

A Letter to My Firstborn 6 Weeks Before the Due Date of Baby Number Two


Dear Aurora: 

I hail from Queerville. 
Well, that's not true. But I like to claim it.
I wasn't lucky enough to be born in Castro or Greenwich;
I actually hail from second generation middle class white Los Angeles suburbia.
Queerville saved me. Actually Queerville brought you into being,
which was a part of my saving, but more on that at another time. 

What I'm trying to say is that 
anything I've done right and anything about me that's wise 
came from an accumulated clear-as-a-bell smartness 
belonging to the queers, the gays and lesbians, the bold bi's,
those who cross and switch and twerk and flame, 
the tender and fierce transfolks, the awesome androgynes,
the polys and kink-inclined. All of them--

they taught me true love, Aurora. It's that simple.

And because they taught me true love, I am now struggling 
(in a way that's not foreign to being human)
with what I know versus what I feel. 
Queers also taught me that knowing and feeling aren't separate,
so in a sense, this struggle is quite faithful. So I must listen to it.
Listen, like radically, listen. 

They taught me that there is always enough love
and any perceived deficit 
is probably some kind of trauma-induced pain that needs working. 
They taught me that, yes, there are limits on/to love, but not deficits 
and learning the difference between limits and deficits 
is how you heal that trauma induced pain. 

So for years I've been learning and swimming in and sometimes resisting 
the spaces betweeen my perceived deficits and truthful limits. 
In all honesty, I think I'm doing pretty good these days, at the age of 32. 
Anything the queers taught me about love, you, Aurora, have solidified,
albeit unknowingly, with the grace of your presence in my life. 
Mothering is just a doubling down on any lesson of love you've learned 
prior to the occassion of becoming a parent. 

All this to say: I've learned and I've become better. Thank God. 
But right now, staring into the future, there is something calling out to me
to be rigorously honest about how perceived deficits/limits 
are fuzzing like some impossibly gorgeous horizon 
induced by a sunset that you just don't want to quit.  

You see: you and I have about 6 weeks left together. 
Your brother, Isaiah, is supposed to be born on October 24th
and while every ounce of me can't wait to behold him,
every ounce of me is also grieving the loss of me and you. 
Not that we are going anywhere, but a glacial shift is about to happen between us.
There is always always always loss in change. 
And you're too young to get what this change will entail for us.
I feel kinda guilty about that,
but more than anything I feel responsible 
for our collective grief--yours and mine--
in an anticipatory way. 

I am so fucking in love with you. 
What your little life does to me in indescribable. 
What I see in your eyes
What I hear in your babble
What I feel in holding your toddler body
What I sense in witnessing your becoming--
I am so fucking in love with you. 

Part of me is reluctant to share that love. 
There I said it. 

There's a part of me that still believes,
somewhere down deep, 
even though the queers taught me different,
and i "know" different,
that I only have so much room
and only have so many resources
and only have so much time
and only have so many ways
to love
and that when Isaiah arrives 
some of what's available in me will go to him
and you will be left wanting--
the thought of which makes me spiritually sick
and sorrowful in my guts.   

Is this some capitalist-imperialist ideology in me?
Or as the spiritualists would say: "deficit model thinking"? 

For a long time I thought it would be just me and you. 
Just me and you and you and me. 
Maybe it's because I (mostly) grew up with a single  mom
and learned to trust life in that dyad. Or maybe it's because 
I never thought I'd settle into a romantic relationship secure enough
to also contain parenting alongside romance and knew knew knew
I couldn't parent more than one by myself. But up until J.R. arrived
and then Isaiah came along, I thought it'd be momma and kid, only. 

I was prepared for that. I'm not prepared for this. 

I'm not prepared to share my heart with any other little being than you. 
I want to give you everything I have. 
I don't want to have to choose between you and anything else, ever. 
I don't want to be split. 
I want ultimate harmony with you, 
a circadian dance where your needs, the legit ones,
are met by the innate supply G-d has implanted in mommies
for the eternal supply of offspring. 
I'm not prepared for this. 

This morning you woke up late. 
I brought you into bed with me, 
so you could drink your bottle and I could give snuggles
all at the same time. 
Just lingering in that moment, 
feeling the fleeting seconds go by--
will we have this kind of time in 3 months from now?-- 
was enough to bring me to tears. 
And so I stayed. 5 minutes turned to 10.
10 minutes to 20. 20 to 45. 
I was late for work and couldn't care less. 
And then, then I had to write. 
Because even though you will only be this little for so long
and even though I will only have one child for so long
there is nothing that can take my written words away. 
 
When you are older
and I am gone
or I'm still here but you are curious about what it used to be like,
I want you to read this and know-- 
that in the last weeks before Isaiah was born
you were in my constant thoughts
and i was summoning every lesson from Queerville 
that I could possibly summon
because I need to believe, now more than ever, 
that love will make room, will expand, will multiply,
will unlock places in me that i never even knew existed. 
Because I've never ever ever loved anything the way I love you
and I want every single thing that I do, 
including giving birth to and raising another child,
to make my love of you more palpable, more felt, more real. 

The queers have never lied, never led me astray. 
If you understand, years from now, from the context of our relationship,
or in the Spirit of this writing, the difference between limits and deficits,
and most importantly about the power of love 
to create more of itself from itself,
please be sure to give credit where credit is due. 
That is all I ask. 

Love, 
Momma 

Sunday, September 8, 2013

A Snapshot


That's my pelvis. 
Pressure. 
Those are my dreams. 
Tornadoes in the distance. 
These are my feet. 
Swollen. 
This is today. 
A snapshot. 
That's my family. 
Like the best mix tape you ever heard. 
Those are my blog entries. 
Word from flesh. 
These are my hopes. 
Expressed. 
Those are the freedoms I miss. 
Flexibility and time alone. 
These are the hands I cannot live without. 
J.R. 
That's my heart walking around in a body. 
Aurora. 
This is 32.5 weeks, full full full. 
Isaiah coming. 

Thursday, September 5, 2013

Writing Isaiah Entry #18


Writing Isaiah 
Entry #18
September 5 2013

Lois Parr

Hey...so many things to think about on this side of pregnancy...with two sons who live on the other side of the country, following dreams and becoming who they are meant to be. There is no wonder that you are always writing about body/flesh-y things, as you are an interpreter of Incarnation (THE Incarnation, big I, of Christian belief; all incarnation, word/God-made-flesh in everyone/living thing. So...because I am (we are) so often thinking/doing the examination of the intersections of oppressions, I am wanting to ask you (a young womyn who could be my daughter) about the unfinished business of the feminist movement of the generations before me and of my generation: which is to say, the way that sexism hurts the men we love. I should back up to say that I so wanted a daughter, and when I had sons, I asked Gloria Steinem (really, I did this in a huge auditorium) "how do I raise my sons to be feminists the way I had planned to raise my daughter?" her response was something like "pretend they are your daughters." But then I had two sons, and you have Aurora & Isaiah...how do we help our sons be the kind of men who understand the fullness of their own humanity (yes, this could be about the body, too, or about queerness...but I am talking about things like the willingness to cry in public, or to listen better, or to re-define what "strong" means...if you know what I mean...

Emily Joye McGaughy-Reynolds

This prompt elicited two immediate responses from me: grief and sluggishness. For many many years, from a place of unmistakable woundedness, I had no investment in men understanding their humanity because in all honesty I didn't think they had any. So when I read your prompt I felt grief for that period of my life and for the ways in which I can still lose hope in men (which happens more often than I would like to admit). Then I felt sluggish: can I even write about this? Can I write about the way "sexism hurts the men we love?" I feel like such an amateur at loving men, like truly loving them. And when it comes to my feminism (and the unfinished business of the movement), I feel much safer working in the realm of loving/empowering/serving womyn. However, I know, because I've listened deeply, again and again, to your generation of feminists and to my own conscience, that we cannot leave men out of feminist practice/theory/realities/movements. It only serves to solidify patriarchy. And having said that, there's still a little voice within, an old begrudging voice, that claims: 'just don't make them the center of everything because they already are, everywhere.' Just the other day I was talking to J.R. about how hard it is for me to witness other white anti-racist activists get all buddy buddy in communities of color but refuse to do the work among their own kind. It seems to me a disavowal of where 'some' of the 'real' disruption of oppressive dynamics and infusion of loving subversion needs to take place. I guess what I'm saying is that I hope to see and act, clearly and decisively, where oppression actually is. And since I know so much oppression exists inside of men and gets enacted through men, I cannot possibly hold up the feminist banner without being willing to hold/fight/love them. 

And, having said all that, the big queer in me, capital Q, wants to deconstruct the very premise of the conversation by pushing back on the notion of static gender. But that's not what you've asked me to do here. I'm going to employ some 'strategic essentialism' (to use Spivak's theory) in the full knowledge that doing so runs risks, probably does harm, and limits me but it's risk, potential harm and limits I'm willing to face. Why? Because I've done lots of work around gender deconstruction, but very little in the way of parenting a  feminist son (if he indeed becomes a son, which he might and might not). I think I need this exploration for the sake of parenting prep and spiritual maturity. 

About a year ago I was invited by a lesbian couple from Koinonia to attend their middle child's baseball game out in the country between Battle Creek and Union City. Kolin, their son, was one of my favorite youth of the church: spunky, curious, outspoken, active. I wanted to show up for him and, as you know, I love baseball. So this was a no-brainer. When I came up to the ballpark, I noticed right away that these were all rural, working class families, totally white and with the exception of Kelly & Bene (the mommas), totally gender-conforming and hetero. As the game  started, I settled in but I was on-guard, particularly as I listened to one of the assistant coaches (a dad) berate his own kid and use rather demeaning language with Kolin's entire team. I asked Kelly & Bene about him and they both confirmed that he was quite a piece of work. Once he was on my radar, I became hyper-vigilant about watching him. Every time one of the kids made a mistake on the field he would scoff, verbally lash out, or enact some kind of disapproval with his body language. At one point, two players from the outfield--ten year old boys--took too long getting to their positions before the inning started because they were busy chatting each other up and this man yelled out "what are you two girlfriends or something? get to your positions!" What finally made me have to get up and leave is when this man's own son got hit by a pitch in the arm, hard, came walking off the field in tears, clutching himself in pain, and his dad told him to stop being a little "bitch" and to "be a man" after taking a brief look at the kid's injury and surmising it wasn't cause for tears. The entire scenario felt like a case study in "Why and How Men Get Fucked Up Before They Hit Puberty." I left feeling sick to my stomach. I also left wondering if I should have said something--for Kolin's sake, for that son's sake, for Kelly & Bene's sake, but I didn't have enough love in me to say something for that man's sake, so I didn't. I also left with this deep suspicion that the man himself, the dad who couldn't handle an iota of vulnerability or intimacy or injuriability or emotionality in/between men, was gay. And I've gotta say: this was my experience with men at the VA again and again. The most hyper-masculine men I've known have often been drawn to homosocial space (the military, the church, sports) without having to confront the 2 basic drives motivating their need for homosociality: 1) their relentless agenda to prove their masculinity because underneath it all there's a fear of the feminine within & 2) they truly desire time spent with other males but can't just admit that desire without opting into some kind of institutional logic that condones it to the larger public under the guises of service/sacrifice/competition/heroism (read: patriarchy). 

The two basic drives I've named above make sense given how male supremacist, heterosexist, homophobic and sexist our world is. It's also true, however, that everyone, absolutely everyone, needs institutional, cultural, public, social space to work out their identity and to form relational bonds. So when it comes to feminist parenting of a son, my hope is to both provide space and to help my son locate/navigate spaces of his own where identity formation and socialization can happen with integrity. But there's a problem: many of those spaces simply don't exist for men. This is partially their own fault. Many of them, even the best of them, have been conditioned not to create those spaces because the stuff of social life has been considered womyn's domain. They buy into that lie at their peril. But they also spend way too much time fleeing those spaces because their privilege would be threatened by authentic intimacy with others. I've had more than one man bicker and complain that there are "so many options for fellowship/intimacy for womyn at church but nothing for men." But those same men do nothing to organize spaces for themselves. And I think underlying that is a fear of the intimacy that at once promises to comfort and challenge them. True relational engagement requires authenticity, intimacy, vulnerability, a certain level of emotional porousness & precarity (to use Butler's language)--all the stuff we strip men of from the get go. Their levels of physical guardedness, emotional shut-downness, and spiritual defensiveness--and there are exceptions to this generalization--can often smack me in the face when we are in a room together for less than 5 minutes. If they aren't willing to hear about that, I don't want to be in space with them. And I'm not alone in that. Many of the womyn I know, trans/queer/gay men and emotionally integrated cis/straight men too, often comment that being in the company of men is hard because there's no there there. That's what privilege does. It strips us of our capacity to be real because we are busy holding up some facade that in some how/some way appears to 'benefit' us. This is true in predominantly white circles too, I'm afraid. Anyways, all this to say, finding genuine community, spaces for identity formation and socialization is what life, real fucking life, is all about. But that is nearly impossible for those of us who swim in the kinds of privilege and supremacy that cut us off from authentic, honest intimacy with ourselves and each other. Patriarchy is a number one offender in this regard. 

You add to this dynamic the way black men, in specific, are criminalized and sexually fetishized in this culture and it's a recipe for disaster. I fear, dreadfully fear, the intersections of oppression my son will face. But I do not fear more than I believe in and take hope from the power of a Liberator God at work in the world. I'm not just thinking about feminist parenting these days. I need to be a freedom/peace activist and anti-racist parent up in my household too. It's all connected right? So up to this point I've been looking at external/ish dynamics. But now I want to perhaps implicate myself a bit more. What is at the heart of feminism? What would it look like to enact feminism as a mom to Aurora and Isaiah (knowing they will learn both from direct experience with me and from watching me parent the other)? What would it look like to enact feminism as a spouse to J.R. who is spouse to me and father to them (one by choice, one by blood)? What would it look like to enact feminism in my daily walk with God? I think it's true that you teach/ingrain values more by living them than by talking about them. So. Here's my plan. 

The central messages of feminism are, for me, about equality and love of womyn. That is: all genders are equal and loving womyn is important/good/holy/necessary. Maybe I will get into a little gender deconstruction after all. 

There's this passage in Isaiah (the prophetic book) that comes to mind. It's about a time when "they shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruning hooks: nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more." (2:3-4) I often think of the human body as the terrain where the gender wars take up swords on each other. That is, I think all of us are pretty gender multiplicitious yet live in a gender binaried system that prioritizes the myth of bodies being one gender (innately "complimentary" to the "other" gender). Judith Butler has said this so much better than I ever could. So I won't go any further. But I will return to Isaiah. I long for the feminist/prophetic time in history when bodies will no longer be at war within themselves or at war with each other, when we can put our swords down and not cut any gendered reality out, and in fact love love love the many gendered nations within and around us. So: i want to love my sons gendered embodiment in its multiplicity. I want to love my daughter's gendered embodiment in its multiplicity. Same goes for J.R. And for myself. And the congregants I serve. And I want to love them all equally, no matter how impossible that may seem/feel/be. What does that love look like tangibly? Looking, listening, affirming, touching, sharing. Being open to change. Being open to what's foreign. Being open to what's true even when, especially when, it challenges me. Being open to (more/new) love. Being open to being loved (in return). Being open to feedback about the shit I'm not being open to/about. Being a plowshare instead of a sword, which is actually quite difficult for me because i still sometimes believe in and have engrained fear of the constructed masculine and hatred of the constructed feminine and reluctance to w/holy-lovingly-embrace what's Queer/non-conforming/crossing/transgressing in me and you and them and us. Being honest about how hard it is to be a plowshare in these systems even when you honestly and desperately want to put down your sword if for no other reason than you're tired of bleeding yourself. Yeah, I think we stop going to war when we do the hard work of loving equally. Feminist parenting of son rule #1: love all genders equally. 

Loving womyn, specifically. I answered this question for Chris Kindy, kind of, and so I want to go down a different rabbit hole. I've been thinking a lot lately about what it means that I've married a man. And what that will say to my children about where my priorities lie in terms of love. And I've been thinking about the fact that J.R. married a white womyn and what that will say to his children about where his priorities lie in terms of love. Can I still embody a same-gender loving ethic within a heterosexual marriage? Can J.R. love blackness in the midst of a mixed-race marriage? There's a part of me that wants to scream out "YES, of course we can!" But/and. We must contend with the fact that our choices do signify a kind of prioritization. But/and my hope is that the priority is love over identity. Yikes, that's scary to write. My hope is that our love for each other stands next to the other powers of love we hold, and that they stand next to each other in ways that strengthen and cross-pollenate as opposed to erase each other. I think part of that is how well J.R. embodies feminism and how well I respect and highly regard blackness. If you've chosen to love someone who loves what you are, that says something about how you love yourself. I hope Isaiah and Aurora can see the love of womyn and the love of blackness, albeit lived out very differently, through both of their parents. Wouldn't that affirm their own realities? I gotta hope so. There's more at work in them than color and gender and, again, there is more than one gender and more than one color at work in this family, so obviously it's bigger than just these slices of life, but these slices of life are highly contested and so they require a whole lot of attentive, focused, specific love. Right? Feminist parenting of son rule #2: love womyn (and all other marginalized spaces/bodies/life) specifically. 

One last thing. Last night in a womyn's group at church, where we are studying Geneen Roth's book "Women Food and God," a bunch of women talked about the significance a certain passage had on them. It was about how feelings just need tender room to be acknowledged and expressed. Like, what if our mothers and fathers and coaches and teachers had said "come here, sit down. what's wrong? what hurts? tell me all about it. i want to know more" when we were in pain? It took me back to the day on the baseball field. It took me back to that dad who was berating his son for being in pain and shaming his son for expressing that pain. I bet his dad did that to him and his dad's dad before, and so on and on and on. I want to offer something else. I want to coach my son's baseball team and receive every painful tear lovingly along side cheering every home run jubilantly. And when the father's witnessing a new kind of coaching of their sons begin to weep for the parts of themselves left abandoned, berated, and shamed on the little league fields of their childhoods--I want to receive every painful tear of theirs too, in the embrace of authentic, honest love between equals. Something tells me if my son sees that, he'll be okay. And if he doesn't play baseball--well--that's another blog entry for another day.


Thanks friend. 

Monday, September 2, 2013

Sabbath Gratitude

Exodus 20:8-11


8 Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.
9 Six days shalt thou labour, and do all thy work:
10 But the seventh day is the sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates: 11 For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the Lord blessed the sabbath day, and hallowed it.


Thank you
God
for the Sabbath.
For this moment of watching the Tigers play the Red Sox.
Thank you for sending my spouse home
on his lunch break
so that he can eat the sandwich, vegetables and beet chips
I have lovingly prepared.
Thank you for Fall encroaching,
for what I can smell and sense of it already in the air.
Thank you for the email I just received from Sandra,
a simple check in, but profound to me nonetheless.
Thank you for a day off. For a day off. A DAY OFF.
Thank you for the growing boy in my belly,
whose kicks are getting stronger by day
and harder to ignore at night.
Thank you for my daughter, my daughter,
this sensational daughter whose laughter is a light
a lift and drift into love like i've never known it.
Thank you for a home
where calm and quiet surround me, unbind me, soothe me.
Thank you
God
for the Sabbath.
Thank you
God
for my life,
my perfect life.
Thank you
God
that on the Sabbath
I can return to the truth of my life's perfection
and rest in the luxury of gratitude.
Thank you
God.

Friday, August 30, 2013

Writing Isaiah Entry #17


Writing Isaiah 
Entry #17
August 30th, 2013

Alicia Van Riggs 

My question, which is really a reflection of my own experience right now. I'm finding these first weeks of nausea to be similar to earlier pregnancy experience - generalized nausea , all the time. Reprieve can come from various actions - eat, but also poop, pee, fart... It's like the signals from my abdomen are suddenly passed through a mixer before reaching my brain. Is this at all echoed in your experience?  How do you trust these fuzzy signals?   What translation tools do you rely on for internal communications?

Emily Joye McGaughy-Reynolds

There is some stuff in life that feels generally unfair. As in me and you now on our second round of pregnancies so very very far away from one another geographically. I can't believe our pregnancies paralleled each other, time wise, again. Makes the whole absence harder. Like Sunny and Aurora haven't even met face to face and yet we are discussing how to get the snuggle sleeper back to you through the mail. It's kinda cosmic jack-assery that we haven't been able to touch each other's bellies or attend our daughters' baptisms. And NOW we can't even converse about fuzzy body signals with the very subject matter at hand at hand! I miss you Alicia. I miss you tons.

I didn't have generalized nausea and don't relate personally to the symptoms you're describing. They say each person's experience of pregnancy is different and that each pregnancy of an individual is different. Must be true. Sorta. I don't often relate to other womyn's pregnancy symptoms or experience. But there has been a similarity between my two pregnancies with only a slight variation. The second time most everything is the same, in terms of progression, sensation and symptoms, with two exception. This time everything is slightly less intense. Like on a Richter Scale, the experience of pregnancy with Aurora was a 6 and with Isaiah it's a 4. Does that makes sense? The food aversion was there, just not as pronounced. The exhaustion of first trimester had its impact, but not as disruptively this time. Again, the kicking and hiccuping came about in the second and third trimesters but not as forcefully. The (second and) only thing that's significantly different is the weight gain. I weigh right now (at 32 weeks) with Isaiah what I weighed when Aurora was born (40 weeks) and the baby is supposed to gain a 1/2 a pound a week from here on. My body is "heavy laden" so to speak. Imagining carrying this body around, a body that will hold more and more weight, for another 8 weeks, is rather scary, honestly. Some days I come home and strip immediately and just lay naked, sideways on my bed, because even the presence of clothes or having to stand up make me feel oppressed. There's too much. Body. Matter. Weight. I long to be in water. I want some kind of unforeseen gravitational equation to set me free. 

The last two questions of your prompt are intriguing to me. In fact, I love them. Thank you. 

"How do you trust these fuzzy signals?" 

a) I wonder how fuzzy they are. What's the source of the fuzz? Is it the fact that we aren't conditioned to nor supported in developing our carnal ear? What if from the earliest moments of our lives, we'd been told that listening to our bodies (as opposed to silencing them) was the most important listening we could ever do? Something tells me there'd be less fuzz. Of course the body is mysterious. Fuzz would be present in utopia, i'm sure. But there'd be less. My former coach and mentor Wayne Muller used to say "the body never lies." He's right. But Lord have mercy do humans struggle to hear its truth.    

b) How do I trust them (the fuzzy signals)? I guess by practice. Pay attention. Discern. Obey. Discern again. Repeat. Like, with food, for instance. Somewhere deep deep down I believe that whatever my body craves is what it needs. So I pay attention to the craving, discern what it'll take for me to satisfy that craving, obey it, and then discern whether the entire process led to corporeal delight or something else. First trimester it's all about noodles, tomato-based sauces like marinara and ketchup and TONS of gatorade. Balsamic vinegar and diet coke started calling my name in second trimester. And now I can't get enough raw vegetables in third. Like avocados, bell peppers, radishes--totally rocking my world every day. Can't get enough. The more I eat the stuff I actually want, which does include ice cream and/or Hershey's mini-chocolate squares every once in a while, the more pronounced, in a specific way, my hunger becomes. The signals of pregnancy hunger have become more and more trust-worthy over time. It's pretty wonderful. But all the signifiers of pregnancy aren't wonderful. Of course I'm not telling you anything you don't know. With both pregnancies I got plagued with acute anxiety between weeks 6 and 12. Unfortunately I didn't remember going through it the first time when I was going through it the second time, and so I kept wondering: why is this happening? something must be wrong! My colleague, dear sweet Tom Ryberg, reminded me in the 9th week with Isaiah that I'd gone through this, almost exactly the same, with Aurora. What a gift he gave me with that reminder. I keep wondering about the source of that anxiety. Was it too a trustworthy signal from my body? I have to believe on some level, yes. But it was hell going through it. I'd have day terrors about miscarriage, nightmares about dead babies. Torture torture torture. I don't know what purpose that anxiety served but I do trust something necessitated it. Perhaps I'll discover more in the future. One can only hope. 

"What translation tools do you rely on for internal communications?"

Wow. I have to really really think on this. Translation presupposes a difference in language. Or some kind of need for interpretive assistance. This of course takes me back to Marion Grau's class on hermeneutics "Interpreting Bodies." Best class I've ever taken in my life. One thing tattooed forever in my brain from that class is that bodies create interpretations and interpretations create bodies. Both/and. Not either/or. Which is, of course, entirely fascinating and kinda scary to think about when it comes to pregnancy. Do we have a common language? What is it? Is my body the shared language right now? Doesn't that erase some kind of existing separation/distinction between us? Obviously Isaiah is a concrete entity within my body but not synonymous with it. What needs to be translated between baby and mom? And do I have the interpretative frameworks I need to even discern our differences of language. Does the baby? If so, it can't be because he posses some kind of awesome cognition. That's not even biologically possible at this phase in his development. If in fact the baby is able to communicate/translate, signify and discern, there must be some kind of natural (as in bio-mechanical) force at work in that. Like, ugh, God. 

This is actually about humility, I think. Stay with me. 

It's so easy, as the grown-up, as the adult carrying, as the maternal vessel, to assume I know what's being communicated by the baby through my body. But isn't there danger in that? Maybe I'm all wrong when I make assumptions about what's motivating this exhaustion or that craving or this kick or that hiccup. One of the things I'm always always always trying to teach through my ministry is Anais Nin's famous quote: "we don't see things as they are; we see things as we are." Knowing we cannot NOT see things as we are doesn't let us off the hook. I think this fact of our conditioned (not determined) interpreting necessitates that we work even harder to pay attention, to listen, to discern beyond our initial impulses, our initial reactions, our initial connections. This is about allowing the other to remain w/holy other. Maybe I think the baby is thirsty at first, but can I leave room for the possibility that my body temperature is too high and what baby really needs is both a cold drink and a cold shower? Holding out the possibilities for a different word/meaning/understanding is hard when there are no actual words to pass back and forth. This is all through the prehension of feeling. But, oh, what a practice. What a novel novel practice! To hold space through feeling for more feeling. One might consider this the ultimate self-centered navel gaze. But I suppose it's also possible, as it goes with most radically incarnate spiritual practices, that one could slip into a consciousness of one's own multiplicity too. As in listening/feeling for Isaiah's translative Word, I become aware that even here, here inside my own corporeal systems, there are mysteries not my own.  That my life, which belongs to me and yet transcends me, and his life which springs from me and will one day be entirely independent of me, deserves a kind of humility all/ways. A kind of humility that leans in to lovingly listen and at the same time laughs at the absurd idea that I'll ever even remotely understand what I'm leaning in to hear. 

It's funny. I feel like I've ended up saying two wildly different things here that might appear contradictory. But, good Congregationalist that I am, perhaps there's a way of holding them both or squeezing them into a third space. Radical trust in the body. Sheer humility in the mysterious presence of the body. To know and to know you don't know. That's what I'm aiming for, I suppose, in pregnancy, in parenting, in life, with God. 

Love you, my beautiful and far-away friend. 

On the way to Comerica Park


Jazz standards by Rollins 
as we drive to Detroit 
where Miguel & Prince 
will take the field in T-2 hours. 
The ride alone 
is worth the ticket price: 
body to body, 
space for silence and sounds 
uninterrupted by a baby 
or household duty. 
All this after a morning of quiet coexistence 
in separate rooms 
where writing projects unfolded themselves 
to their respective authors.
He sent a copy 
of the outline 
for his upcoming manuscript
and I sobbed reading the chapter headings 
as the baby inside me 
kicked for kicks.  
What a life this married life. 
Who knew? 
Not me. 

Monday, August 26, 2013

Writing Isaiah Entry #16


Writing Isaiah 
Entry #16 
August 26th, 2013

Tricha Grajek 

How has your body/life/mind been healed in new ways since and during your pregnancy?  I can only imagine at this point...

Emily Joye McGaughy-Reynolds 

I remember the first time someone referred to me as a 'healer.' It was my mentor/spiritual-mother/pastor Rev. Marjorie Denise Matthews Wilkes. She was introducing me to someone on the Pacific School of Religion (PSR) campus, someone who had just preached at our Black History Month chapel service, someone who brought me to my knees and brought me to tears all at the same time--a man named Rev. Dr. James Noel. Professor of American religious/church history, incredibly talented visual artist and ordained minister in the Presbyterian church. It was one of those introductions that made my knees shake because I didn't feel worthy to be in the presence of such greatness. And when it came time to introduce me to him, Marjorie put her arm around my shoulder and said "Dr. Noel, this is Emily Joye, current student at PSR. She is anointed, this one. A prophet and healer." When she said it I felt this squishy, uncomfortable sensation in my belly. My eyes immediately hit the concrete pavement and an incredible force of shame washed over me. How could she say such a thing? And especially in front of *this* man? For one, I'd always considered myself mostly broken and in need of healing, not any kind of source of healing in and of myself. Secondly, when I thought of 'healers' back then I thought of folks like Jesus, Gandhi, Mother Teresa...and well, Marjorie...and I was *nowhere* near that level of personhood. Third: I was too tattooed, too activist and angry, too queer, too confrontational, too formerly addicted and confounded to be a "healer." I imagined Dr. Noel could see all of that just looking at me and so I was embarrassed about the gap between what was being said and what I felt was true. Now I know my projections of what Dr. Noel saw merely reflected back what I thought about myself. Problem was: I knew Mama Marjorie was incapable of lying. Her words always have been and always will be "solid rocks" on which "I stand." There's the Word (which is Christ) and there are the words (Christ's treasured earthen vessels who in their unique, personal way incarnate the Truth/Gospel) in our world today. Marjorie is one in the great Other, without a doubt. So in that moment, forced to grapple with the discrepancies between what she said and how I felt, there came a reckoning. Was "healing" a part of my vocation and I just didn't see/feel/know it? 

Ever since then, I've been discerning what 'healing' actually is. Perhaps i'm not alone in this kind of discernment. In some ways I feel like biblical stories/images get in the way for contemporary Christians. We are taught to think of healing in non-consensual, ableist, ex-nihilo models. Like out of nowhere, we encounter suffering on the street, and without relationship, without being asked, we reach over and extend our hand to some poor soul in need and because the power in us is so great, that person is "fixed." What a patriarchal, Western imperialist wet dream that is! Of course there's context for this kind of imaginative conception. While it comes dangerously close to the same ideological power dynamics that exist in colonization and rape, I'd be lying if I said there wasn't biblical, theological and Christological precedent right underneath it. We've got to grapple with this stuff as contemporary believers and theologians. We just do. I've been grappling for a long time. All this to say, when I read/see the word 'healing' there are parts of my conditioned white supremacist, ableist, patriarchal, imperialist thinking/mind that I must work hard, consciously, to identify and deconstruct. 

Tricha, you may think I have forgotten your question totally by this point. But I haven't. You asked me to reflect on healing in the experience of pregnancy. In order to do that, it felt necessary to be honest about the identity and contextual struggles that present themselves whenever I try to engage this topic. So now that I've done that, I'd like to move into more beautiful things. 

Last week my mentor Jo Ann Morris was in town. She sat on my office couch for 3 hours, which felt like the longest drink of water my thirsty soul has had in a long long time. We talked about all kinds of stuff: personal life, family, work, politics, love, justice, etc. But one thing Jo Ann shared with me has been ringing in my ears (and heart) ever since. She has an incredible sense of urgency in the work she does as a professional author, coach and facilitator in the area of diversity. She doesn't let *anything* get in the way of risk, courage and truth-telling (3 things that cannot exist without each other which she reminds me often and is evidenced by her life). When I asked her about what sustains that level of urgency and relentless pursuit of risk/courage/truth in her work/life--she said, "I'm going to die." This is apparently a refrain she is using a lot right now because she referenced it three different times throughout the course of our conversation, once rather casually, once folded into huge husky laughter, once dead-ass serious. "I'm going to die," she reminds herself, she reminds others, she reminds me. 

Is not the fact of death the most healing balm there is? For some it's fear. For others an abstract. But for those who have faced it or brushed up against it, whether willingly or not, there can be an endless supply of life-giving permission in embracing the reality of our mortality.

Isaiah is now 32 weeks developed in the womb. He is flapping, kicking, flipping, hiccuping, sleeping, etc. I feel him (even in stillness) now every single day in a way that I will not feel him soon. This morning, one of the first things J.R. said to me upon waking up is: "little Isaiah was kicking up a storm last night while you were asleep." You know what that means? That means right now, in this phase of pregnancy, my husband is able to spoon me and feel his son's force materialize in the spaces between us. In a matter of 8 or so weeks, that will no longer be the case. When Isaiah emerges (God willing, safely) I will feel his newborn body on my chest, feel him breathing, even feel him move towards my breasts for the first time, which will be the source of his nourishment in the months ahead. And, there will come a time, not shortly thereafter when he will no longer breathe on the stillness of nor fit so perfectly on my chest. Later he will require solid foods and will no longer breast-feed. I know all of this because I've gone through these phases with Aurora. They do not last. They come so beautifully and then before you can even fucking blink, they are gone. 

Things die. They go away. What we have now we will not always have. Acknowledging these realities gives me permission to be fully present in every moment of my life, but particularly those moments that feel perfect. And honestly Tricha, those moments are pretty frequent these days. There's healing in that. Frequent moments of encountering perfection after many many years of not even believing perfection was possible--there's healing in that. 

This morning Aurora began to stir around 8:00 a.m. I was in the living room, storming the key-board in the midst of another writing project. I really really didn't want to stop writing because I was on a roll, and yet J.R. was in the shower and her little voice kept calling over the baby monitor: "babba. hello. babba. mommy. daddy. babba. hiiiiii." Begrudgingly I went to the kitchen, filled a bottle, and then way-less-begrudgingly picked up my baby girl's body and carried her with me back into the living room. She placed herself square in my lap. It was just about that time that Isaiah began stirring within. I had a baby on the outside and a baby on the inside, both freshly awake, both gently moving in their own way. I was between them and yet it felt like the closest we'd ever been. There was a moment when Aurora's soft breathing and Isaiah's tender kicking and my body prehending it all overwhelmed me: how did love find its way to me like this? How is it that I get to be the thin layer of existence that right now separates these two by skin, but once Isaiah emerges will connect them biologically forever? I had no idea my life could or would ever be/feel this useful. 

So healing. 

I've written ad nauseum about the way womyn's bodies are mythologized, disregarded, and trashed in this society. So I won't go into all that here. But I will say that I think 'healing' is about re/discovering power where larger forces have rendered us powerless and therefore mothering (whether biologically or by choice) is an unparalleled time for womyn to discover their power. I've never felt powerless in my body. My body has always been a source of strength for me. I've told you that before. But I have felt absolutely powerless when it came to my capacity to be/do/have family, to bare/bear connective, biological relations and to abide in the love of my bloodline. These perfect moments are healing me from that mythological/narrative about powerlessness by putting me in touch with the power I do have. I cannot tell you what a difference that has made and is making in my vocation. 

Pastoral ministry is full of all kinds of stuff. But one thing we swim in, constantly, are the myths that others bring to our work. Like, folks think we are inherently more spiritual than them, and therefore more capable of insight, prophecy, healing, and leadership. If you are a pastor who likes your ego stroked more than you care about the will of God being done, you will confirm these myths for people while losing your soul. If however you know that you are going to die and everyone else is going to die and that time for folks to discover the Gospel in themselves (as opposed to perpetually discovering the Gospel-according-to-their-pastor) is limited, then you earnestly and hopefully humbly get about the business of putting people in touch with the power they do have--which is always, as St. Paul the Apostle reminds us, the power of God at work in them. Often that will entail deconstructing the myths of power they carry about themselves, others and God. Some people will not hang out for that part because it gets wickedly fucking uncomfortable. "Never under estimate the inclination to bolt." Right? Many of those myths give people their sense of identity, sense of world, sense of place. Destabilizing that is risky. But/and. My friend Kayla Bonewell used to have a quote on her Facebook that seems relevant here: "World-views create worlds." They hammered this into us in seminary. I think partly because if we dared going into a 'healing' profession, we better know that what often stands in the way of people's healing are the worlds and views they hold to be true. If people's views/myths/narratives of power are rendering them powerless, there's no way to heal from that except through deconstructing those views/myths/narratives about power and creating new ones. Which is of course about facilitating space for people to tap into and experience their own power, like women's writing group and our fitness group with Taryn. Not an easy (pastoral) task if people think that a pastor's job is comprised of listening compassionately and giving answers. But I'm getting ahead of myself. Creating new ones--views and worlds--doesn't happen all at once, though it does happen simultaneously. It happens in this really interesting matrix-y kind of way where you do new stuff that makes you think new stuff. Or you think new stuff which enables you to do new stuff. And then all of a sudden your thinking and doing are dancing to a different beat, shifting forms along the way, passing information back and forth, enticed, like best friends on an old sofa telling each other radically risqué and totally tender love stories. 

Pastors don't heal people. People who heal (which pastors can be part of, of course) do so because they courageously move into discomfort, dance bravely into new territory and willingly embrace and share widely the gifts that come as a result. Because of my own healing experience, I have come to think of my pastoral duties differently. I don't heal people. I make space for people to move, dance, embrace and share. Healing happens in those spaces if God and humans collide. Sometimes they do. Sometimes they don't. Whether it happens isn't my responsibility. Making the space is my responsibility.  
 
In that regard I think many of us on this Earth are 'healers.' Mama Marjorie was right about me, and, I'm just one of many. I suspect Tricha that you are one of many too. In fact, I know you are. And I cannot wait to see how your current pregnancy and those to follow will engage this question/prompt of healing in your own life and in the life of others. Be sure to write back. Some day. 

Love,
eeJ 

Sunday, August 18, 2013

Sermon Writing & The Preaching Moment: Memory, Family, Religion & Power

Just spent the last 24 hours writing a sermon about family values. Now I need a vacation.

Seriously though...

Part of the experience of writing that sermon included a memory/flashback to the 6th grade. It was 1992 and that whole Dan Quayle/Murphy Brown mess was all up in the news. My pastor, Rev. Dr. Homer "Butch" Henderson preached a sermon about "family values" that changed my life forever. I don't use that phrase lightly. Literally: changed my thinking about family, about values, about the Bible, about being a Christian. That sermon is responsible, in large ways, for the beginnings of my feminism and queerness and my introduction to progressive Christianity, biblical hermeneutics, and theology. Can I even quantify or qualify my life without those things? Would I be a pastor today without that sermon? Would I have the family I have fought to incarnate without that sermon? How is it that a preacher can have that much power? 21 years later and I still remember that sermon. I was eleven years old dude. Eleven.

Dear God: may I never ever forget the life-transforming potential of preaching. May I always be responsible and faithful to you first and foremost, and then, carefully, tenderly, powerfully willing to give the best of what I have (from you) to the flock who so surely deserves it. Amen.

Friday, August 16, 2013

Achieving Mental Sanity in the Morning: A Formula

If you wake up in the morning and you're nuts
like bat shit crazy
wheels spinning
anxiety soaring
no anchor, no root, no tether to speak of--
welcome to the pressures of pastoral ministry
(or just the normal stuff of human-being-awake, literally and figuratively).

While it's presumptuous to think there's a once-size-fits-all remedy
to pre-sunrise panic, I'd like to share what worked today,
yes for you, my beloved readers, but more for me, in case I forget
and need to be reminded of a formula-for-relief later down the road.

Move your body out of the bed before any one else stirs.
Give thanks for a moment of quiet.
Make the coffee extra hot.
Eat a peach.
Wrap a hand-knitted, prayer soaked blanket around your shoulders.
Read James Baldwin. Read that paragraph that you underlined,
the one that knocked your fucking socks off, at least three times.
Read the bible, specifically a parable, about seed-sowing and 3 types of soil.
Remind yourself: what kind of soil you choose to be is up to you,
and it has everything to do with how you listen and how you respond.
Pray in the silence. Ask for help, specifically, with the shit that vexes you--
name it, name them, name yourself. Then see how it feels to acknowledge your limits.
Give thanks for a place to be powerless, in all honesty.
Pet the dog whose needs are real. Let the dog out, whose bladder is real.
Hug the college student, the one whose like a daughter to you,
before she goes back to NY. Squeeze her tight: it's going to be a while.
Tell her about a dream you had: about how she doesn't ever have to choke,
not for the sake of anyone. Give thanks for feminist writers who taught you not to choke.
Go back to bed and stare at your spouse holding your child,
behold how their still-sleeping bodies signify all that truly matters.
Crawl back in with them, snuggle as a threesome for a while,
 and after taking the baby back to her crib,
make love to the person whose partnership you cannot fathom living without.
Feel it: the connection, the intimacy, the love, all in skin. Feel it.
Get up. Go to the kitchen. Play Ice Cube's "It Was a Good Day"
and give thanks for growing up on early 90's Los Angeles hip hop,
while stirring the pancake batter with just enough force to leave some luxurious lumps.
Prepare yourself, mentally and physically, for door-knocking in an hour,
because queers are the liberation of the Earth and they deserve legal protection.
Write something to remind yourself that there's thinking and then there's living.
And living is best just.like.this.

Love,
self.